FIX IT - Health Care at the Tipping Point DVD

This video was produced by the president of a multimillion dollar company, MCS Industries, in Pennsylvania who eloquently points out how of the rapidly escalating and unpredictable costs of healthcare are his biggest expense the biggest threat to his solvency as business and why he favors single payer (single risk pool, unified payer) health care.  The full video is about an hour long, the shortened version is 40 minutes. There is a three minute trailer as well on the disc.

If you are interested in seeing the video or obtaining a copy, please contact us and we will make it happen.

Fix It Healthcare - At The Tipping Point a powerful new documentary that reaches across the political and ideological divide to expand support for major healthcare reform.

Here is what Ralph Nader has to say about FIX IT in a recent Huffington Post column:

Just when the prospects for single-payer or full Medicare for everyone, with free choice of doctors and hospitals, appear to be going nowhere, from Pennsylvania's Lehigh Valley comes a stirring that could go national and make single-payer a reality.

Throwing down the gauntlet on the grounds of efficiency and humanness, businessman Richard Master, CEO of MCS Industries Inc., the nation's leading supplier of wall and poster frames, is bent on arousing the nation's business leaders to back single-payer - the efficient full Medicare for all - solution.

The woefully wasteful and profiteering health care industries have blocked majority opinion, and a majority of physicians and nurses, to keep the present sky-high costly system in place, that receives huge taxpayer subsidies without any reasonable, and meaningful, price restraints. Health care companies exploit the complexities of Obamacare, which is powerless to restrain price spirals (note the staggering rise in recent prices of certain drugs). But the health care industry cannot defeat an organized business community fed up with uncontrollable cost burdens and the further competitive disadvantages they experience with western European countries, Japan or Canada - countries that have single-payer systems at half the per capita costs or less.

Mr. Master's first step is now complete. He has produced a short movie called "Fix It: Healthcare at the Tipping Point" which makes a powerful business case for replacing the current wasteful multi-payer system with a single payer one. He traveled with his award-winning filmmakers to Canada, where he interviewed doctors, nurses and conservative business people. The latter were aghast over why their fellow conservatives in the U.S. are not seeing the light.

One industrialist, Dann Konkin, told the filmmakers that he embraces the Canadian healthcare system because it reduces his company's costs. The film quotes Michael Grimaldi, former president of General Motors of Canada, as declaring that the Canadian healthcare system "significantly reduces total labor costs for automobile manufacturing firms." His predecessor, Jack Smith, who went on to head the entire General Motors, said much the same. more

You can help MVHCA as we work for publicly funded universal health care like the rest of the developed world by donatinghosting a house party, signing up for the newsletter, and attending our monthly meetings. You can also Like us on Facebook, and Follow us on Twitter. Thank you.

A Small Business Owner's Case for Single Payer

Op Ed by Small Business Owner and Health Care for All PA Past-President Dave Steil in June, 2013

Affordable alternative

Better care at a lower cost

Health care, its delivery, quality, coverage and cost is the most perplexing and challenging issue facing the business community today. There is nothing more important to a business in the management of its operations than knowing the cost of each component of those operations.

When it comes to health care protection for employees, however, those costs are difficult to understand and to control, especially for small business owners who wear many hats and must deal with day to day challenges while still finding time to ensure that the long term plan is also in place. As a small business owner, my struggle to find a balance between those responsibilities is ever present.

Since World War II health care has principally fallen upon the shoulders of business. That means that it was discretionary for business owners to provide or not provide health care to employees. Frequently, that meant a hard working individual had to depend on the employer’s health care plan being a major beneficial component of the business cost and competitive structure. When the plan failed to be beneficial, the employer was free to drop employee health care. As costs rose and competitive conditions changed, many business owners did just that. Often it was imperative for the business to remain viable.

With the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in 2010, businesses are, for the first time, required to provide health care to their employees. Businesses smaller than 50 employees are exempt but their individual employees must now buy insurance to cover themselves and their families.The total impact of these changes to the health care system is not yet known to business owners, but are much feared.

More and more business owners are asking the question, why is health care still our responsibility? Why do we continue to perpetuate a seventy year old system that is costly and leaves many hard working people without health protection of any kind? Business owners know their products and services. They are not schooled in health care administration. But, if we accept that question then we must ask, if not business, then who?

There are in reality only two answers to that question. Either every person must provide for his or her own health care protection or it must become a core function of government, just as is education. In fact government already provides close to 50 percent of all health care, through Medicare, Medicaid, Military (including VA) and government employees.

Many will reject this option without ever looking at the facts. That is regrettable and intellectually dishonest. In fact, now there is now solid data to support the concept of a State of Pennsylvania managed health care system that would cover all Pennsylvania citizens for most health care related needs.

An economic impact study (EIS) just released by Health Care 4 All PA, a Pennsylvania non-profit corporation, clearly demonstrates that health care can be provided to all citizens at much lower cost than is already being paid by business and individuals. Known as the Pennsylvania Health Care Plan (PHCP), administered by the state, it would provide comprehensive health protection by removing the significant costs associated with insurance based and directed coverage. The cost of the plan would be paid for by personal income and payroll taxes, but at a lower rate than is already being paid for health services.

For businesses there are many added benefits directly reducing the costs of doing business:

  • Lower direct costs than the cost of the insurance based system Reduced Workers Compensation costs
  • Reduced cost of general liability insurance
  • Elimination of costs to administer the insurance plan by the business
  • Equal ability to compete for employees in the job market
  • Increased ability to compete in the international marketplace
  • Elimination of legacy costs for providing retiree health care
  • Less confrontational collective bargaining
  • Clear and identifiable costs for budgeting purposes

Legislation to adopt the PHCP presents an historic opportunity to overcome the complexities and uncertainty of the Affordable Care Act and to put Pennsylvania in the forefront of advanced and enlightened health care. Nothing else that we could accomplish would create a business climate as economically attractive as the PHCP.

This is not just a health care management plan, but a major job creation engine. If the business community rally’s behind this proposal it will happen, because we, collectively, carry a powerful voice.

David Steil, Lower Makefield, is a small business owner and a former member of the state House of Representatives.

Help MVHCA on the road to true universal health care, by donating, hosting a house party, signing up for the newsletter, and attending our monthly meetings.